Custom Goodness

Please be advised that we will be on Winter Break from 12/20/23 through 1/20/24. The final day for all pick-ups, deliveries & shipments is 12/20. All online orders placed during winter break will be responded to beginning the week of 1/22/24. Thank You & Happy Holidays!!

our baking philosophy

We believe quality, freshness, and taste are equally as important to the appearance and craftsmanship of our designs. We use only the best ingredients including organic, free-range eggs, real butter, pure vanilla, high quality gourmet chocolates and cocoa powders, fresh lemon juice & zest, berries and local organic seasonal produce. We do not create run of the mill, mass produced bakery cakes or cookies made with artificial ingredients, powdered mixes, and pre-made fillings. All of our items are hand-designed, baked from scratch and freshly made to order.

Our cakes vary greatly in price depending on several factors including: size, flavor options, and design details. They can range anywhere from $3.50 per serving for a basic cake up to $12 per serving or more for intricate, tiered wedding designs. We are happy to work within your budget and accommodate any request you may have. However, please understand you are commissioning us for a high-quality, one-of-a-kind, custom item.

custom order policy:

custom cake sizes

Custom cakes are available in several sizes with standard & deluxe flavor options. Gluten Free and Vegan Cakes are Available upon request. All of our custom cakes are constructed with 3-layers of cake & 2 layers of frosting with a plain exterior crumb coat. Due to this fact, our custom cakes are taller (6” or greater) than our celebration cakes, which are 2-layer (approx. 4” in height).

The pricing below reflects base pricing.

cake size party servings banquet servings pricing
4"
4
6
$25-$35
6"
8
12
$30-$40
8"
14
28
$45-$60
10"
20
42
$65-$85
12"
28
56
$125+
14"
62
78
$175+

*Tall Cakes (4+ layers) is an additional charge starting at $25.
**Tiered Cakes (2 or more cakes stacked upon one another) are $100+ added to the cost of the individual cakes.

Standard Cake Flavors

Vanilla
Devil’s Food Chocolate
Lemon
Coconut
Almond
Red Velvet

deluxe Cake Flavors

Princess White
Carrot
Confetti
Marble
Chocolate Chip
Strawberry
*Seasonal: Blueberry
Apple Cinnamon, Spiced Pumpkin

Standard Buttercream Flavors

Vanilla
Chocolate
Lemon
Coconut
Almond

deluxe Buttercream Flavors

Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter
Salted Caramel
Confetti
Cookies & Cream
Cookie Butter
Fruit Infused: Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry

additional options description pricing
custom fillings
Fresh Fruit, Compote, Preserves, Curds, Custards, Ganache, Mousse, Cannoli Filling, Cookie Dough, Nutella, Cookie Butter, Streusels
$20+
standard celebration decor
Piped Buttercream Ring at Top of Cake, Rainbow/Chocolate Sprinkles at Base & Top Accent
$20+
exterior effects
Vibrantly-Hued Buttercream, Rough Edging, Colored/Smooth Stripes, Concave/Convex Stripes, Watercolor, Colored Stucco *Fondant Covered Cakes ($50+)
$25+
cake enhancements
Chocolate/Colored Drip, Hand Painted Fondant Banner, Fondant Name/Message, Cardstock Number, Piped Buttercream Details, Fancy Sprinkles, Metallic Details
$20 Each
deluxe enhancements
Fondant Details, 2-D/3-D Characters, Sugar Paper Details, Fresh Florals
$50+

We are happy to try to accommodate any request you have.

Custom Cake Order Form

  • Max. file size: 300 MB.
If you do not wish to fill out our order form, please email us
Goodness Cafe 26003-Edit
Goodness Cafe7557-Edit

Goodness Cakes

Our Goodness “Topped” Cakes are a popular and easy way to customize your cake. They include your choice of standard cake flavor & standard buttercream filling, a tinted smooth buttercream exterior, piped buttercream accents, chocolate/colored drip, sprinkles at base and edible toppings to fit your desired color scheme.

Edible Topper Choices (Choose 3):

PB Squares, Mini Chocolate Chip/Sugar Cookies, Cookie Dough/Vanilla Cake Truffles, Dipped Shortbread Sticks, Sugared Marshmallows

cake size pricing
6"
$100
8"
$120
10"
$150

Goodness Cake Order Form

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Custom Cake DISCLAIMER: If you have chosen to pick-up your custom cake, we are NOT RESPONSIBLE for any damage to your cake once it is in your possession. Cakes are FRAGILE. While we attempt to honor any/every design and décor request you have, some cakes are simply more fragile than others. Please consider this when placing your order. If damage should occur during transport or thereafter, any repairs or replacement cakes (when possible) will be subject to additional fees. Thank You.

Custom Cookies Order Form

  • Max. file size: 300 MB.
If you do not wish to fill out our order form, please email us

Follow Us For More Goodness

Ready to
Place Your Order?

Let's Talk.

Send me your order ideas and
I will get back to you shortly!