Custom Goodness

Custom Cakes

Custom cakes are available in several sizes with standard & deluxe flavor options.

All base prices are for a 3-layer frosted cake w/ no decor.

– 6” Serves 6-10 ppl/$30-$40
– 8” Serves 12-16 ppl/$45-$60
– 10” Serves 20-26 ppl/$65-$85
– 12” Serves 40-48 ppl/$110+


 Tall cakes (4+layers) are double the base price.

Standard cake flavors include vanilla, princess white, devil’s food, lemon, coconut, almond & red velvet.  Deluxe flavors include carrot, confetti & seasonal. Standard buttercream flavors include vanilla, chocolate, lemon, coconut and almond.  Deluxe frostings include cream cheese, peanut butter, salted caramel, cookies & cream, confetti & seasonal.

Additional Options:

– Custom Fillings (Fresh Fruit/Compote/Preserves, Lemon Curd, Vanilla/Chocolate Custard, Ganache, Mousses, Cookie Dough) – $20+

– Décor – Starts at $20 (for simple celebration style w/ rainbow sprinkles) & increases in price based on intracacy of design/decor
– Tiered Cakes – $100+ (added to cost of individual cakes)


We are happy to try to accommodate any request you have.




*All Custom Cake orders require a minimum of a 1-week lead time (*2 weeks from May through October) from details finalized & confirmation (payment in full) of order. More elaborate cakes may require additional lead time. Cakes ordered outside of the lead-time (if accepted) will be subject to a rush fee starting at $50.

Custom Cake DISCLAIMER: If you have chosen to pick-up your custom cake, The Goodness Café is NOT RESPONSIBLE for any damage to your cake once it has left our premises. Cakes are FRAGILE. While we attempt to honor any/every design and décor request you have, some cakes are simply more fragile than others. Please consider this when placing your order. If damage should occur during transport or thereafter, any repairs or replacement cakes (when possible) will be subject to additional fees. Thank You.

Custom Cake Order Form

Custom Cookies

Custom designed and decorated cookies are an excellent way to personalize a sweet treat and are also easily shipped. They make great party favors!

Custom cookies require a minimum of 1 dozen per order and start at $50 per dozen. Cookies can be individually wrapped, and also adorned with ribbon and custom tags or labels for an additional charge.

*All Custom Cookie orders require a minimum of a 2-week lead time (*3 weeks from May through October) from details finalized & confirmation (payment in full) of order. Cookies ordered outside of the lead-time (if accepted) will be subject to a rush fee starting at $50.
Custom Cookie DISCLAIMER: The Goodness Café is NOT RESPONSIBLE for any damage to your order once it has left our premises, whether you are picking up or your order is being shipped. Thank You.

Custom Cake Order Form

Custom Dessert Displays & More

The Goodness Cafe is available to design a custom dessert display for any party or occasion that will provide lasting sweet memories. A $100 NON-REFUNDABLE deposit is required to reserve your event date.  Cost of individual desserts range from $2-$7 per item.  When determining the amount of desserts for a display, we suggest 3-4 pieces of dessert per guest and a minimum of 5 different dessert choices, however we are happy to work with any theme and budget.

Delivery & Set-up charge starts at $250.  Design & Creative Consulting services starts at $250 and includes designing custom desserts, selecting decorative elements, creating backdrops, tablescapes, signage, etc., to fit a desired theme or aesthetic. A service charge of 20% of the dessert total will be applied to cover use of service pieces and necessary equipment.  Once details are finalized, 50% of the Invoice is due, with the remaining balance due 1 month prior to event date.  Every party and occasion is unique and we are happy to try our best to accommodate your desires.

Custom Cake Order Form

Follow Us For More Goodness

Ready to
Place Your Order?

Let's Talk.

Send me your order ideas and
I will get back to you shortly!